Charity trusteeship is a really challenging role. You’re responsible for looking after a charity’s assets on behalf of its beneficiaries, and that’s important – it’s a position of trust. And it means that in many ways you’re held to a higher standard than the leaders of other organisations, despite being (usually) unpaid.
But trustees aren’t expected to be perfect, and their decisions don’t have to be perfect either. What the law actually says is that your collective decisions should be ‘within the range of decisions that a reasonable trustee body could make’. David Holdsworth, CEO of the Charity Commission, has confirmed explicitly that: “the Commission is not here to second guess trustees who make tough decisions in the face of straitened financial circumstances and do so within the law and our guidance” and “so far as decisions are taken in the best interests of the charity, in line with its purposes and following our decision-making guidance, we’ll have your back. We won’t come down hard on trustees simply because their decision was unpopular or subject to criticism”.
At Bates Wells, we’ve specialised in advising the charity sector for decades and we work with so many amazing trustees leading the way on systemic change, scientific breakthroughs, transformative care, pioneering research, purposeful litigation, tackling injustice and so much more. It’s what makes our job so interesting and so rewarding.
The flip side though is that, as lawyers, we do also see what happens when things don’t go to plan. In the rush and stress of making a difficult decision, important information or steps might be overlooked, and it might be harder than usual to see the bigger picture. Equally, trustees who feel very certain that a particular end result is the correct one may end up dominating a discussion, leaving other trustees feeling there isn’t room to question or even delay what’s proposed. And if in the heat of the moment good records haven’t been kept of the reasons for the decision, it can then be hard to justify the decision later to people who are trying to understand how this can be in the charity’s best interests.
So when an important, controversial or difficult decision needs to be made, how do we make sure it can stand up to scrutiny? What does it actually mean to make a decision that is ‘within the range of decisions a reasonable trustee body could make’?
From my perspective as a charity lawyer, if you’ve made a ‘good’ decision it should feel a bit like this:
1. We had enough information to make this decision. We’ve read the papers, we’ve asked questions, we’ve taken any advice that we need, and we’ve asked for more information if we felt there were any gaps. We can confidently say that this is an informed decision.
2. We weren’t swayed by anyone’s personal interests, preferences or relationships – this decision was made in the best interests of the charity. Our trustees and senior staff have been asked to declare their interests, and if any of those interests were relevant to this decision we’ve managed this properly.
3. We understand the likely impact of this decision on our charity and our stakeholders. We’ve got a good sense of what our stakeholders, and the wider public, will think about it. We’ve either consulted about the decision, or we’ve made a conscious decision not to consult and we can explain why.
4. We’re clear that our charity has the power to do this.
5. We’ve assessed the risks and taken them into account when making our decision.
6. We looked at all the realistic options (including doing nothing) and this option feels like the best one (or the least bad!)
7. We’ve thought about what a critic, a complainant, the media or a regulator might say.
8. We considered carefully whether there were any other relevant factors we should take into account, and we’re confident that our decision reflects all the relevant considerations.
9. We’ve shown our working. If anyone asks us why we made this decision, we have a written record of our decision-making process and we will be able to explain the rationale for this decision confidently.
Ultimately, this is not about reaching the ‘right’ decision that everyone agrees with – often, that simply isn’t possible. Trustees will sometimes have to make decisions that are difficult, finely balanced or unpopular, and you can’t guarantee those decisions won’t be scrutinised. But what you can do is make sure that, if your decision is challenged weeks, months or years later, the trustees can go back to the record and say: this is what we knew, these are the options we considered, these are the risks we weighed up, and this is why we concluded that this was the best decision for our charity.
The material in this article is provided for guidance and general information only and is not intended to constitute legal or other professional advice on which you should rely. In particular, the information should not be used as a substitute for a full and proper consultation with a suitably qualified professional. Please contact the Bates Wells team if you require further information.