Healthcare organisations regularly receive requests for records from relatives of patients who have died. These requests can raise difficult questions about what information can be shared and who is entitled to access it.
The UK data protection regime – the UK GDPR and the Data Protection Act 2018 – only applies to living individuals. But that doesn’t mean that health records of deceased patients can be provided (or withheld) without further consideration. The relationship between a doctor and patient is one of confidence, and the common law duty of confidentiality continues to apply even after the death of the patient. Additionally, the Access to Health Records Act 1990 creates a formal right of access for certain individuals to a deceased person’s health records in England, Wales and Scotland.1
So how does a healthcare organisation decide how to respond to these requests? This article will look at the legal background before considering a step-by-step approach to requests for deceased individuals’ health records.
Legal background
Common law duty of confidentiality
The common law duty of confidentiality (the “duty”) arises where information is shared with a reasonable expectation of confidence. It generally covers information patients give their doctors2 and continues after death, so health records must remain confidential unless disclosure has legal authority or justification. The duty was established by the courts; case law recognises when it may be breached, and legislation can override it. The Caldicott Principles reflect the duty’s application in healthcare, supporting confidentiality and appropriate use of patient information.3
Access to Health Records Act 1990
The Access to Health Records Act 1990 (the “Act”) has largely been replaced by the UK GDPR, except for provisions allowing access to deceased patients’ records and, under the Adults with Incapacity (Scotland) Act 2000, records of living patients lacking capacity. It allows a deceased patient’s personal representative,4 or anyone who may have a claim arising from the death, to access health records held by a “health professional”.5
Access is subject to partial and full exemptions, discussed below. Those with a potential claim may access only records relevant to it;6 a personal representative’s access is not restricted in this way.7
Responding to a request for health records
Healthcare organisations should first consider if the requester is entitled to health records under the Act, or – if not – whether the request will need to be considered in the context of the general duty of confidence. There is no particular form in which a request under the Act must be made. This means that even if a request does not refer to the Act, healthcare organisations should still consider whether the requester is eligible for the records that they seek.
1. Who is subject to the Act?
The Act applies to health records which are made by health professionals and held by record holders in England, Wales or Scotland.
2. Who is a health record holder?
In simple terms, the health record holder is the person, organisation, or NHS body that is legally responsible for keeping a patient’s health record. If the record was created as part of NHS services, this will usually be the NHS organisation or healthcare provider responsible for delivering those services. If the record was created outside those arrangements, the holder is generally the healthcare professional who keeps the record.8
3. Who is a health professional?
A health professional is an individual who is professionally qualified and registered to provide healthcare, such as a doctor, nurse, midwife, dentist, pharmacist, optometrist, osteopath, chiropractor and so on. The definition, which is drawn from section 204 of the Data Protection Act 2018, also includes child psychotherapists and certain senior scientists working in NHS bodies.
4. What is a health record?
A health record consists of information that relates to the physical and mental health of an individual who can be clearly identified in the record (or by using information in the record and information known by the health record holder).9 The information must be recorded on or behalf of a health professional in connection with the care of that individual.
This is a very broad definition which encompasses both electronic and written formats, as well as expressions of opinions and facts. Health records may therefore include consultation notes, referral and discharge letters, test results, x-ray films, photographs, audiotapes and even tissue samples taken for diagnostic purposes.
5. Who can make a request?
Personal representative of the patient
The Act does not define “personal representative”, although it is usually the person who holds the probate documentation or is named as executor in the deceased’s will.10 Health record holders must be satisfied that the requester is the deceased’s personal representative – for example, by requesting documentary evidence. A personal representative is not required to give a reason for their request.
Person who may have a claim arising out of the patient’s death
Someone who may have a claim arising out of the patient’s death can request access to the deceased’s health records, but only to the extent the records are relevant to the claim. This is typically a member of the patient’s family pursuing a financial claim but could encompass other claims as well. The Act does not provide a definition of a ‘relevant claim’, and so the decision as to whether a claim exists lies with the health record holder. As above, the holder should satisfy themselves of the requester’s right to access the records through requesting documentary evidence and should seek legal advice where the position is not clear.11
6. Are there any exemptions?
Against the deceased’s wishes
The health record holder may withhold a health record in full if the deceased expressly indicated, prior to their death, that they did not wish for their records to be provided.12
Other exemptions
The health record holder may withhold any part of a health record which would disclose information that:
- is likely to cause serious harm to another person;13
- relates to an individual other than the patient or a treating healthcare professional14 (unless that individual has consented or it is nonetheless reasonable to disclose it);15 or
- the holder has reason to believe the patient would have felt particularly sensitive about and would not have expected the disclosure.16
In general, health record holders should refuse access to health records only to the extent necessary. Where an exemption applies, the health record holder should normally redact or withhold only the affected information rather than refusing access to the entire health record.
Decisions about whether information should be withheld from a requester must be made in conjunction with advice from an appropriate healthcare professional – ideally, someone who previously treated the deceased patient, or otherwise a suitably qualified health professional.17
7. How long do we have to respond?
Health record holders usually must respond to a valid request within 40 days.18 However, if the health record was created, added to or amended within the 40 days before the request, the response must be provided within 21 days.19
If the health record holder requires additional information from the requester (i.e. to establish their right to make a request), then the clock stops until that information is received.20
8. Is there anything else we should consider before disclosing health records?
- The Act does not apply to records created prior to it coming into force on 1 November 1991.21
- Health record holders cannot charge a fee for the provision of health records under the Act.22
9. What if the Act doesn’t apply?
because they are not the executor of the deceased’s will or do not have a claim arising out of the deceased’s death), the health record holder may still disclose the health records where disclosure can be justified in the public interest.23
Because the common law duty of confidentiality still applies, the public good that comes from disclosure must outweigh the obligation of confidentiality owed to the deceased patient.24 Key factors to consider include whether:
- the deceased patient authorised or prohibited the sharing of their health records while alive;
- disclosure would be beneficial to the deceased patient’s family, or would otherwise cause unnecessary harm or distress;
- there is a recorded next of kin or previously registered Power of Attorney;
- there are any other statutory duties which would prevent or enable disclosure.25
How can we help?
If you would like any help understanding your organisation’s obligations under the Access to Health Records Act 1990 or the common law duty of confidentiality, please get in touch with us. We can help you in responding to specific requests for health records or to establish an internal policy on how to deal with requests in the future.
1The corresponding legislation in Northern Ireland is the Access to Health Records (Northern Ireland) Order 1993.
2Hunter v Mann [1974] 2 All ER 414.
3The Caldicott Principles — UKCGC.
4Subsection 3(1)(f) of the Act.
5Section 2 of the Act.
6Subsection 5(4) of the Act. [1] Re AB [2020] EWHC 691 (Fam).
7Re AB [2020] EWHC 691 (Fam).
8See section 1 of the Act for further details of health record holders in England and Wales and Scotland respectively.
9Section 1 of the Act.
11Department of Health, Guidance for Access to Health Records Requests.
12Section 4 of the Act.
13Subsection 5(1)(a)(i) of the Act.
14Subsection 5(1)(a)(ii) of the Act.
15Subsections 5(2)(a) and (b) of the Act.
16Subsection 5(3) of the Act.
17Section 7 of the Act.
18Subsection 3(5)(b) of the Act.
19Subsection 3(5)(a) of the Act.
20Subsection 3(6) of the Act.
21Subsection 5(1)(b) of the Act.
22Subsection 3(4) of the Act.
23Department of Health, Guidance for Access to Health Records Requests.
24Department of Health, Guidance for Access to Health Records Requests.
The material in this article is provided for guidance and general information only and is not intended to constitute legal or other professional advice on which you should rely. In particular, the information should not be used as a substitute for a full and proper consultation with a suitably qualified professional. Please contact the Bates Wells team if you require further information.