Media disputes

We defend freedom of speech and protect reputations.

The two are not mutually exclusive.

We recognise the vital importance of freedom of information and freedom of expression in a free society; we also recognise that reputation and privacy may need defending, in particular against unduly intrusive reporting and against fake news.

In relation to freedom of speech we act for authors, journalists, academics, campaigning organisations, membership bodies, book and newspaper publishers,  broadcasters, and citizen bloggers – keeping them out of trouble, or resolving disputes when they are in trouble.  We also assist businesses, people in the public eye and charities protect hard won reputations. We’ve handled landmark Freedom of Information Act cases and we specialise in new media and internet litigation. In 2000 we took the first ever case against a libellous, ‘anonymous’ emailer to court. We’ve broken ground ever since.

How we help

If defamation threatens your name, your privacy’s been compromised or your copyright’s been infringed, we’ll protect your reputation – in public, in print and online. We aim to give you fast, robust advice. We will seek to get material taken down, and to secure corrections and apologies. And if going to court is the only way to prevent publication or clear your name, we’ll start proceedings.

If you’re a publisher, we’ll support your right to speak out, to obtain information (including from public authorities and the courts) and report on the issues you uncover. We will seek to clear what you want to put out, against the law and any relevant regulatory codes (including the Ofcom Broadcasting code), and seek to give you realistic practical advice on the risks.  If things have gone wrong we will defend you in court or before the regulator.

We recognise that whoever you are, we may need to move very swiftly to protect your position.

Relevant work for those seeking to publish information

Helping expose corporate wrongdoing

Before charities or campaign groups such as Amnesty International, Action Aid, Shelter publish articles exposing controversial practices, they may seek our advice. We help to ensure their reports are accurate, in the public interest, and won’t lead to costly defamation or IP infringement claims.

Uncovering information

Using the Freedom of Information Act, we helped historian Andrew Lownie to secure publication by the University of Southampton of the diaries and letters of Lord and Lady Mountbatten, blocked by the Cabinet Office. believed to be the largest amount of information released pursuant to a FOIA request.

Protecting media sources

We advised a source for stories in the national media about the predatory sexual activities of an MP, balancing the source’s desire for confidentiality against their desire to see the media successfully defend an action for libel and privacy brought by the MP. The MP’s action was abandoned after service of witness statements, before trial.

Defending and resolving libel claims

We acted for The Sunday Times and its journalists, David Walsh and Alan English, in helping successfully to resolve a claim for deceit against Lance Armstrong in relation to monies paid out in the cyclist’s earlier libel action against the paper and its journalists.

Keeping costs down

We acted for The Times in the Supreme Court and European Court of Human Rights in a case which resulted in the Government conceding that success fees should not be recoverable from publishers in defamation and privacy cases. The decision affected the whole media landscape and was a victory for freedom of speech.

Work to protect reputations and confidential information

Securing apologies

We represented Prince Nayef in High Court litigation when the Independent and Robert Fisk accused him of ordering the police to shoot protestors in the Arab Spring. The newspaper apologised and paid damages.

Tracing online wrongdoers

We acted for a City analyst to track down who was posting false profiles of them online, portraying them as an adulterous antisemite. We commenced a claim in defamation, harassment, privacy and false attribution against persons unknown, obtaining disclosure orders against Microsoft, BT, Twitter, Facebook and a recruitment platform, to trace the culprit. The evidence was provided to the police, who were able to recover the culprit’s computer and prosecute. Subsequently we brought a successful civil action for defamation, harassment and false attribution to obtain an apology and recover all the client’s costs.

Protecting confidential information

We secured a High Court injunction on behalf of the Advertising Standards Authority against publication by a complainant of confidential communications mistakenly emailed to him, carefully negotiating the challenges of dealing with a litigant in person.

Meet our team
You May Also Be Interested In

Mitigation, not litigation: let us help you avoid costly disputes

Our dispute resolution health check can identify and remedy potential issues that could cause you a problem in the future. Read more on how the health check could help your organisation.
Read more

A review of our litigation team’s positive impact

As we reflect on our work over the last year, we are proud of the extensive impact our litigation team has made to the lives of so many people. Download the report below to read about some of their most impactful work from Autumn 2020 to Summer 2021.
Read more

Bates Wells wins Litigation Team of the Year and Pro Bono Initiative of the Year at The Lawyer Awards 2021

We are absolutely delighted to have won two awards at the hugely competitive Lawyer Awards 2021. Our first award was for Litigation Team of the Year and is testament to the work the team has done to secure various groundbreaking judgements over the last year. The Lawyer commented on one such groundbreaking judgement – the …
Read more

Diversity in action: A guide for charities

With diversity and inclusion high on the agenda across the third sector, we’ve produced a guide for clients looking to develop and instil best practice in their charities. In this guide, we’ve included a range of specialist advice and practical guidance designed to help you negotiate the law and to incorporate good practices into your …
Read more

Our B Corp reaccreditation results are in…

We are delighted to share our B Corp reaccreditation results for 2020. Click the link below to view.
Read more